While my editorial opinion has been fairly obvious in these articles, I feel the need to express them directly.
The fundamental truth that is missed in the media and those in government and finance close to the microphones is that this did not start with the borrowers — it started with the investors who bought securities backed by non-existent mortgages and non-existent and/or non-negotiable notes.
The world credit market froze up not because of a some bad loans in the United States or a decline in property values, but because the paper — nearly all of it — was bad paper. It wasn’t bad risk management or even lack of regulation that caused the meltdown, it was the investment banking community’s boldness in violating every law, rule and regulation known to State and Federal regulators.
They forged documents, destroyed documents and “lost” documents, because to produce them would have been an admission of criminal fraud. The reason the credit markets have frozen up is that bankers, who will tolerate stupidity and bad judgment in each other, will not tolerate outright dishonesty and lying.
Investors will not come to the table to buy securities from the thieves who stole from them so recently. Paulson’s “bailout” package was ridiculous. He has no idea how to apply the money and rightfully so — the package was designed to help the thieves instead of the victims. The statement intended was that the U.S. government will not let the infrastructure fall. The statement was heard as a government that was owned and controlled by the thieves dipping into taxpayer money under cover of scare tactics. IT WAS A MESSAGE THAT SAYS THIS BEHAVIOR WILL BE TOLERATED IF IT IS BIG ENOUGH, AND THAT IT COULD HAPPEN AGAIN.
Free markets are free only when there is a referee who blows the whistles, issues penalties, and otherwise disciplines the players. Imagine a basketball, football or baseball game without any referees. Here the regulators were part of the scheme, as were all the participants, because they were creating money and keeping most of it. The fear that letting the big players go down will destroy the infrastructure is a myth and is causing policy decisions to be made that are just plain nonsense.
Like it or not, this was a case of selling securities under false pretenses, intentional misrepresentations, and cover-ups that were worthy of the arrogant Watergate and other scandals. There are thousands of banks, investment banks, and insurers who can step in to fill the void created by the collapse of the major players here who caused this and only by letting them fall can we send the signal to the world that the United States doesn’t tolerate such bad behavior and will let the consequences fall where they may.
There are tens of thousands of insurance policies covering errors and omission, title, and fiduciary responsibilities for the appraisers, mortgage brokers, and lenders that were party to this gigantic fraud. It’s a lawyer’s dream.
The selling of these securities defrauded millions of people, government entities, pension funds, hedge funds, mutual funds and companies who thought they were buying cash equivalent securities when in fact they were buying garbage.
Like it or not, millions of people were solicited into signing up for mortgages they didn’t need or want and where the terms frequently changed at closing. There was no precedent for banks not caring whether the loan worked or not. Everyone assumed that the underwriting departments would reject toxic waste loans. That they effectively closed their underwriting departments because they were not at risk and were paid a fee of around 2.5% to look the other way as they “rented” their charter to unscrupulous unregulated, unregistered players.
In addition to the investors, the victims here are the borrowers, cities and states who were fooled by the apparent increase in prices caused not by demand for homes or mortgages, but by supply of money that was illegally created.
The plain fact is that nearly ALL the paper is worthless, there are no mortgages, there are no notes, and there are no obligations. Nearly every homeowner who took a mortgage between 2001 and 2008 is entitled to have their home declared free and clear of any mortgage encumbrance or debt. That is why the paper is worthless. And in world finance the knowledge of that awesome fact has created doubt and suspicion about the rest of the credit market which is 100 times the size of the mortgage credit market. Nobody trusts anybody in risk management, rating of securities, appraisals, or representations. THAT CAN ONLY BE RESTORED BY COMPLETE TRANSPARENCY AND EASY WAYS TO CHECK THE VALUE AND QUALITY OF SECURITIES.
Over a year ago and several times since I have proposed a “bailout” that required no money from the Federal government, demonstrated our good intentions to make amends, and to restore the investors and borrowers, as much as possible, to their position before the Great Fraud of 2001-2008 took place.
All that is required is an equity appreciation clause or instrument that writes down the mortgages back to real value (i.e., real proceeds from sale if the property were sold) and shares the increase in value that time always provides between the the investors and the borrowers — not the banks and investment banks. The latter already got paid several times over. The “notes” were evidence of obligations that had been satisfied several times over and unilaterally changed at the whim of thieves after the loan closing took place.
AT THE PRESENT TIME, VIRTUALLY EVERY PARTY SEEKING TO FORECLOSE ON HOMEOWNERS IS WITHOUT THE AUTHORITY OR EVEN THE KNOWLEDGE TO ENFORCE OR EVEN KNOW WHETHER A NOTE IS IN DEFAULT BECAUSE OF ALL THE OTHER PARTIES THAT WERE ADDED TO THE REVENUE STREAM AND THE DIRECT BREACH OF EVERY NOTE WHEREIN THE APPLICATION OF PAYMENTS SHOULD ONLY BE MADE TO THE OBLIGATION OF THE BORROWER — NOT SOME OTHER BORROWER OR GROUP OF BORROWERS WHOSE ALLEGED OBLIGATIONS HAVE BEEN COLLATERALIZED BY THE PAYMENTS OF OTHER BORROWERS.
THIS MEANS THAT VIRTUALLY EVERY LAWYER WHO ADVISES OR REPRESENTS A HOMEOWNER IN DISTRESS IS WRONG IF THEY SEEK ONLY TO DELAY OR CREATE A “WORKOUT.” THEY SHOULD SEEK TO WIN.
EVERY BANKRUPTCY LAWYER WHO FILES A SCHEDULE SHOWING THE HOUSE AS ENCUMBERED AND THE CREDITORS AS SECURED IS ALSO WRONG. THOSE BANKRUPTCY LAWYERS ARE GIVING UP A GOLDEN AND NECESSARY OPPORTUNITY TO FILE SCHEDULES THAT DO NOT SHOW THE ALLEGED LENDER AS A SECURED CREDITOR AND THEREFORE BLOCKS THEM AT THE THRESHOLD WHEN THEY SEEK RELIEF FROM STAY.
The government’s attempt to paper over this crisis is dangerous and wrong. It floods the market with even more new money when most of the money out there is declining in value daily. It creates the environment for hyperinflation that could go on for years. If you really want to stop the crisis the answer is to tell the truth and correct the REAL problems. Settling with homeowners with reasonable mortgage terms that they can afford and with equity appreciation clauses of secondary mortgages can restore some if not all of the value of the securities the investors bought and takes the U.S. government out of the business of being the investor of last resort.
Of course this is just my opinion and I can’t offer legal advice to anyone outside of Florida, so check with your local counsel, who probably knows nothing about securitization. My advice is legally without value in any other state so you must seel local lciensed counsel in order to comply with the laws of your state which prevent you from having access to lawyers who really could help.
Like this:
Like Loading...
Filed under: CDO, currency, Eviction, foreclosure, GTC | Honor, Mortgage | Tagged: AIG, AMbac, bailout, borrowers, foreclosure defense, foreclosure offense, investors, POLICY | 18 Comments »