US economics: One big Ponzi scheme – Opinion – Al Jazeera English

EDITORIAL COMMENT: When the Arab News Media reports more than our own regarding Wall Street, you have to wonder whether the world is just turned upside down.

While Bernie Madoff languishes in jail, bankers continue to profit as the poor lose their homes and hope.

Danny Schechter Last Modified: 20 Feb 2011 08:28 GMT
Wall Street traders represent the elite of the global financial world, but after the collapse of the economy those behind the world’s depression still seem to be doing just fine [GALLO/GETTY]

Thank you, Bernie, for breaking your silence – even if you are still clinging to that cover-up mode you adopted since you took the entirety of the blame for your crimes.

What is clear is that ripping off the rich is punished far more severely than ripping off the poor. The lengthy sentence you were given spared countless other greedsters and goniffs from facing the music – what music there is.

In an interview – with a reporter from The New York Times who is writing a book to cash in on a man who has already cashed out – we learn, in the vaguest terms, that Mr M believes the banks he did his crooked business with “should have known” his figures did not figure. Keeping with the deceit that has served him well over the years, he names no names.

That said, how right he may be. There were many who should have known and done something about it. The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and other regulators for one. Perhaps The New York Times for another. Remember, it was Madoff’s confession to his sons that started him on his way to his new 12′ x 12′ home from home – in a federal correctional institute, where he may dream of his seized penthouse, homes and yachts – rather than any press expose.

For years, he went undetected by business journalists, who knew – or should have known – what he was up to. There are even questions about the speed with which he was sentenced, preventing him from being tried – a process which, through diligent cross-examination, would have brought us more information on the details of his dirty deals.

Do not believe all you read

Even The New York Times interview is being disputed, reports the New York Post: “The trustee representing thousands of Bernard Madoff’s victims disputed a report that he personally grilled the Ponzi monster in prison.”

“There has been no direct communication between them,” said David Sheehan, the chief counsel for the court-appointed trustee, Irving Picard, after The New York Times reported that Picard and Madoff had met over the summer.

The Times later changed a quote from Madoff and altered some text online that had implied Picard personally visited Bernie in the Butner, NC, lockup where he is serving a 150-year sentence. Picard did not dispute that his legal team met with Madoff.”

Madoff is also still not coming clean about the web of alliances he had internationally, as well as in New York. We live in a global economy after all. We now know of Swiss and Austrian connections – but what about Israel, where this ingratiating handler was well known for his connections with Jewish philanthropists and institutions? So far, that story has yet to be told.

At the same time, the people investigating Madoff are making a small fortune. According to the Financial Times: “The army of lawyers and consultants helping to recover funds from Bernard Madoff’s $19.6bn fraud stand to earn more than $1.3bn in fees, according to new figures that detail the cost of liquidating the huge Ponzi scheme.”

The comments of readers to The Times appear to be more insightful than the paper’s own reports. Here is one from Texas: “I actually, sort of, feel sorry for this man. He was just doing what many investment firms were doing at the same time. He has been imprisoned as a scapegoat – yet many people since then – and to this day – are doing the same thing. Where are the indictments against the thousands of other people who did the same thing – and knowingly led this country into financial disaster?”

Banks close ranks

The best reporting on this subject is not in the mainstream press but in a music magazine, Rolling Stone, where Matt Taibbi investigates why the whole of Wall Street is not in jail: “Financial crooks brought down the world’s economy – but the feds are doing more to protect them than to prosecute them,” he charges.

Madoff also believes the banks who serviced him did not want to know about his Ponzi scheme which, unfortunately, is probably true – and an attitude coming not just from the banks.

The Times report added: “He spoke with great intensity and fluency about his dealings with various banks and hedge funds, pointing to their ‘willful blindness’ and their failure to examine discrepancies between his regulatory filings and other information available to them.

“‘They had to know,’ Mr Madoff said. ‘But the attitude was sort of: “If you’re doing something wrong, we don’t want to know.”‘”

Yves Smith of quips: “This sounds credible – but it also seems more than a tad self-serving.”

Andrew Leonard asks in Salon: “Should we trust him? After all, if there is one thing we know about Bernie Madoff, it is that he is one hell of a liar. But as evidence emerges that bank executives were exchanging emails wondering about Madoff’s amazing investment record, the possibility that the banks were purposefully looking the other way is not inconceivable.”

The truth is that many of us still do not really want to know – because, if we did, we would have to do something about it.

By their actions, both Democrats and Republicans clearly appear to prefer the most simplistic understandings – or misunderstandings.

The Financial Crisis Inquiry Commission (FCIC), like the 9/11 and Warren Commissions before it, avoided key issues. The FCIC inquiry did not call for a criminal indictment of wrongdoers. While informative, its report was ultimately a dud – telling us mostly what we knew, although there were some disclosures that our tepid press still missed.

Now the Republicans want to water down the regulations on derivatives in the Dodd-Frank financial ‘reform’ legislation, claiming they will lead to a loss of jobs. This is predictable: Every effort to defend big business is always couched in terms of helping the public.

The New York Times reported: “Representative Stephen Lynch, Democrat of Massachusetts, warned: ‘You think regulation is costly? How about the $7trillion we just lost from not regulating the derivatives markets?'”

There was no response from his colleagues.

So who will do anything about it?

The political right prefers to change the subject, while the left does not seem to have the time or energy to make economic justice its principal concern – even as polls show the economy is the number one problem for most in the US.

Progressives should hang their heads in shame at the minimal amount of activism taking place against the banks and the escalating numbers of foreclosures. Homes and hope are being stolen from people for whom the term “depression” now has a personal, as well as economic, meaning.

The other day, economist Jeff Sachs – who has a lot of atoning to do for his own misguided, destructive economic advice to Russia after the fall of the Soviet Union – warned that little is being done about economic inequity and the growing ranks of the poor in the US. He asks if people who run things in the US want “another Egypt”. He is a policy wonk, not an activist – and likely fears the idea.

Many activists say they want to emulate the Egyptians, but who will organise anything as effective – even in a land that used to be known for people’s movements – to raise hell? In Egypt, young people used the internet to organise and mobilise for change. In the US, the internet seems to function more as an escape valve, consuming hours of our time and giving us another way to talk to each other – and ventilate against the government. Social media here seems to be more for socialising.

The government supports internet freedom abroad – but restricts it and spies on it at home. Obama has already supported a law allowing him to shut it down here in a national emergency.

The passivity of the public is one result of the inundation by middle-of-the-road media and effective information deprivation.

As Noam Chomsky puts it: “The population in the United States is angry, frustrated and full of fear and irrational hatreds. And the folks not far from you on Wall Street are just doing fine. They’re the ones who created the current crisis. They’re the ones who were called upon to deal with it. They’re coming out stronger and richer than ever. But everything’s fine – as long as the population is passive.”

That is our problem, Bernie. Even if the people want to know, it is not that easy to find out. Let us thank the media and our government for that.

News dissector Danny Schechter edits His new film, Plunder: The Crime of Our Time, tells the story of the financial crisis as a criminal tale.  He can be reached at:

The views expressed in this article are the author’s own and do not necessarily reflect Al Jazeera’s editorial policy.

10 Responses

  1. Mike H,
    Who runs all US media?
    Their not reporting on any of it intentionally, just like they didn’t report on America’s 23 year old Rachel Corrie being murdered in occupied Palestine by israeli IDF, but attempt to blow up some bogus story about Lara Logan being ‘raped’ in Egypt even after it has been confirmed she was not raped at all and received no severe injuries whatsoever, but the so-called incedent is being used as was intended from the get-go, a provocation.

    Our media for the most part does no honest reporting on issues critical to average American knowledge, they amplify propaganda and keep us in a state of delusion by keeping us misinformed and it’s all intentional.

    Look at history people, we’re not the first country to suffer from all these problems we face and they’ve all generated from the same basic source with the same overall intentions, and as long they’re ignored they will continue to go unchecked.

  2. Faith – Kennedy tried to warn us.
    Correct – so did Regan when he said we will someday tell our children about capitalism and how we (US) blew it. Socialism is simple to define. A fed fund rate under zero brought by hyper defaltion. Japn goin on its third ddecade of RE errors and losses.

    What happened over the last few years is beyond imagination and i am shock the media, public or even this site has yet to divulge the truth about BofA HSBC, Wells Fargo and Citigroup. BofA especially having taken out Countrywide – wow. Its heavy to say the least .


  3. Kennedy tried to warn us.

  4. Dear Dying Truth,
    I think you missed the point. He was commenting
    on Al-Jezeera’s reporting of the Wall Street Crisis
    and saying that it is closer to the truth than the US
    Media. Certainly Al-Jezeera appears to be run by
    Arabs so what is the problem. He is complimenting
    them not putting them down!

  5. I’m not a Middle Easterner, but I find your comment about “the Arab News Media” to be VERY INSULTING to me as an American because it reflects on the rest of us very poorly by (incorrectly) portraying Arabians as people who are somehow ‘less than’ Americans. This all the more further proves Judaism’s (and its followers) racist ideology.

  6. Everything was a lie start to finish and is a continuing lie.They feed us what they want us to believe and being the sheeple that we are we just follow where the leading RAM is taking us, truly disgusting that this is the example we are teaching our next generation.

  7. Read the second paragraph of the Declaration of Independence: it gives us the right to revolution. Should have listened to T. Jefferson, Hamilton, Washington, etc. and stuck with it.

  8. What I think, is it’s not going to be planned in America.

    It’s going to take a few more wacks at our balls.

    Once they hit the food or drug button, it’s going to be what may be called foreclosure winter. But I don’t know. Something gotta give eventually.

    We may just be to soon into this, probably 25% into the dip is my guess. It may take some weitd natural catastrophic event to blow us into the grand canyon.

    Blame wikileaks, not the crminals it exposes! LOL

  9. Simple: Locate a symptom, for instance the foreclosure crisis, reverse engineer from the now openly exposed frauds to where the money and properties flowed to, such as a bank, and do the math as to where that bank channels to, a bigger bank or market by which funds do the disappearing act internationally. Where did the money come from in the first place? Investors. How was the carrot drawn? High returns. Any accomplices? The politicians. For what? Unjust gain. Any more victims? Elderly, children, teens, the working man, the family, the schools, the pensions, healthcare, the entire sustenance and sometimes lifelong investment of the basic hard working family and the middle class and poor, pillaged by those who already have more than they need. The problem? Excessive greed for money, pleasures and power.

    Now, realize the fact, this is all driven by a deep seated addiction, at so many levels. The tolerance dynamic of any addiction means it will not reverse, nor will the addicts be able to regain control. It’s systemic and structurally embedded in a fundamental error in the system.

    The error? Trusting your money with a group community that has made the deal an art, and greed, money obsessions and pleasure drunkenness a science. Obviously the also perfected the ponzi formulaic linearity of it. On that linear timeline, is where the cure to the addiction is found. Forced withdrawal due to system dysfunction to collapse. This is a system of financial core socio-cide.

    Sad, if it was some homeless guys under a bridge smoking crack, cigarettes and Steel Reserve, but this is our leaders. LOL

    God help us, better than the judgment of addicted self-righteousness, come what may.

  10. It’s like the banks are sinking the Titanic, imagining they are not in the same overall boat.


    Wikileaks, and this site too, make me wonder if what we are seeing is but the tip of the iceberg.

    Am I naive? Of course it’s just the tip. Imagine what they are really hiding. Nasty people…

    I had a feeling it was a big lie, LOL

Contribute to the discussion!

%d bloggers like this: