Editor’s Note: Unconfirmed reports say that McCollum is looking for a job in the banking sector.
National Media Takes Aim At Jacksonville Foreclosure Court
@ November 12, 2010 6:54 AM Permalink | Comments (3)
The article, written by Matt Taibbi, is a critical look at the proceedings inside the Duval County courthouse and one of the multiple retired judges trying to clear a massive back-log of foreclosures, Judge A.C. Soud.
It characterizes the process as full of “fraud” because it claims most of the big lending institutions can not come up with a legal paper trail to document who owns the homes being foreclosed on, and the payment history.
However, Florida Attorney General Bill McCollum has characterized the process very differently in recent interviews.
When asked on CNBC recently whether there are examples of homeowners’ property rights being trampled on, and whether there are cases of homeowners being evicted when they are not in default, McCollum simply said “That would be very rare, and most of this is technical,” referring to the paperwork problems in foreclosure proceedings.
McCollum characterized the foreclosure crisis in Florida as a problem that is keeping property values low and Florida’s economy from recovering, rather than a problem that is forcing people out of their homes en masse.
“If there’s no confidence in the (foreclosure) process, and there are a lot of bad titles out there, it would be a disaster for us recovering in the market, with the tens of thousands of properties we have out there in the market,” McCollum said in an interview on the FOX Business Network.
McCollum said as many as 25% of properties being foreclosed on in Florida are abandoned, and many of the property owners have not paid their mortgages in 2 or 3 years.
In Jacksonville it was recently revealed that JEA, the city owned utility that provides power to Duval County, is paying to keep power on at abandoned and foreclosed homes. While that cost is substantially less than it would cost to send crews to each home and turn the power off and on, it highlights the myriad of hidden costs being heaped on top of Floridians already struggling to keep their heads above water in a recession, and pay their own mortgages on time.
According to the property-tracking website Zillow.com, property values have fallen in Jacksonville 15.4 percent year-over-year on average, and that amount is higher in historically poor and minority neighborhoods.
But the huge hit to property values isn’t just confined to those neighborhoods with the highest percentage of foreclosed properties. Riverside and Avondale, recently named as one of the best areas to live in the country by national publications, have seen double-digit declines in property values in the same time period. A quick drive through those areas, and you will notice an uncommon number of “fore sale” and “for rent” signs in historically upscale communities.
And while those properties would have demanded top-tier rental or purchasing candidates a few years ago, a check of local rental websites tells a tale of reduced expectations from landlords who are now competing with properties that won’t sell on the open market, and are being rented at a discount.
“It seems like a fairly simple process,” wrote a man commenting on the story on the WOKV Facebook page. “No one is “kicking” anyone out of thier(sic) homes, they have not paid for the homes, they don’t own them.” A local soldier who lives at area beaches also said he is barely keeping his head above water because of how upside-down he is in his mortgage, and fears for his future if he has to leave the area and sell his home.
A caller to our WOKV Listen Line said he’d recently been through the very court in question, and said “my lawyer told me I had a zero percent chance of winning, and she said every single case that goes before that court, the homes are sold.”
Filed under: bubble, CDO, CORRUPTION, currency, Eviction, foreclosure, GTC | Honor, Investor, Mortgage, securities fraud | Tagged: Florida, McCollum, taibbi | 13 Comments »